NEW REPORT: Hostile Housing—The Health Impacts of Housing for People Seeking Asylum

Migrants Organise and Medact are proud to publish Hostile Housing, a new report outlining how asylum accommodation is harming the health of people seeking protection in the UK.

ABOUT THE REPORT

Co-authored by Migrants Organise and Medact, with research led by general practitioner and population health researcher Dr Joanna Dobbin, the report argues that the “for-profit model” is delivering an agenda of hostility and “containment over care” which is contributing to what researchers term “triple trauma”: trauma from conflict, trauma during migration, and trauma induced by Britain’s hostile asylum system. 

RESEARCH FINDINGS

The findings, drawn from a survey of 60 people living in asylum accommodation, predominantly asylum ‘hotels’, reveal:

  • Overcrowding, damp, poor ventilation and mould leading to respiratory problems, skin conditions and mental health deterioration.
  • Majority of respondents in catered accommodation reported experiences indicating serious problems with food access, including, poor quality, limited variety not eating despite feeling hungry and skipping meals. Two-thirds of people rated food quality as poor. Children were significantly affected, with half refusing meals daily and over half experiencing weight loss.
  • Over half of respondents felt unsafe in sharing complaints with accommodation staff. A third were not allowed visitors, while those in supported accommodation faced time restrictions around leaving sites.
  • Respondents reported being watched and monitored, feeling unsafe, and raised concerns about staff. 

As the Home Office moves to shut down “asylum hotels,” the report shows there is a need for safer, community focused housing models. In particular, the report recommends that asylum accommodation should be placed in the hands of local authorities who can prioritise not-for-profit community housing models. 

Jawad Anjum, report author and Housing Justice Organiser at Migrants Organise states: 

“Our report exposes an asylum housing system prioritising containment over care and de-facto detention over dignity. Private contractors like Clearsprings are making huge profits from people’s misery in so-called ‘hotels’ and barracks. 

We are urging the government to place asylum housing into the hands of local authorities and partners on a not-for-profit basis with accountability from the people who have to live in it. Our asylum accommodation model needs to be built on the principles of community, dignity and care for each other. It’s time to build communities not camps.”

Dr Joanna Dobbin, report author, general practitioner and researcher at UCL and member of Medact states: 

“The current asylum system is more focused on deterrence than the well-being of people within it. People are often subjected to years in substandard accommodation, which is detrimental to their health and the health of the communities they are living in. Accommodation centres run by companies like Mears, Clearsprings, and Serco—have led to people getting sicker, while those companies get richer. This report highlights the impact housing can have on health, and the opportunity we have to build something better.”

The Migrants Organise Housing Justice campaign demands safe and decent housing for all. It’s time to put people over profit!

Migrants Organise is a platform for migrants and refugees to organise for dignity and justice. Join our mailing list.